Question · Keyword Rank Tracker

Why do keyword rankings differ by location and device?

Short answer

Keyword rankings differ because Google picks results for each search, not one list for everyone. Relevance depends on the searcher's location, language and device, and the position you see can also depend on your search history. So the same keyword can rank one way in Paris on a phone and another way in Hong Kong on a desktop.

What changes the order of results?

Google says relevance "is determined by hundreds of factors, which could include information such as the user's location, language, and device (desktop or phone)" (Google Search Central). Its example: a search for "bicycle repair shops" shows different results to a user in Paris than to a user in Hong Kong.

  • Location – where the person searches from.
  • Language – the language the person searches in.
  • Device – a desktop computer or a phone.
  • Search history – your own position "might be different than the average because of many variables, such as your search history, location" (Search Console Help).

Search Console does not show one search. For every search where your site appears it records the topmost position of your link and then averages these values (Search Console Help). Your own search is a single sample from your place, your device and your account, so it can be higher or lower than that average.

Search Console also splits the numbers by country and by device in the Countries and Devices tabs of the Performance report (Search Console Help). If a page had impressions on desktop but none on mobile, the mobile position shows a dash (Search Console Help).

How do I compare rankings fairly?

Change one thing at a time. Two checks are comparable only when they match on:

Keep the sameWhy
KeywordOther words are another search
Search engineGoogle and Bing are separate search engines with their own results
CountryLocation is one of the relevance factors
DevicePhone and desktop results can differ
PageSearch Console reports positions for each page separately, in the Pages tab

Then repeat the check over days and look at the trend, not at one number.

What will Keyword Rank Tracker check?

Keyword Rank Tracker by Never Zero Lab is still in development and not in the Chrome Web Store yet. In the current build you choose the search engine, Google or Bing, and one of 30 countries; you cannot choose a city or a device. The position comes from a Never Zero Lab server. How that server searches, and how accurate its positions are, has not been tested yet, so its numbers may differ from what you see in your own search.

How to check rankings with the tools you have today: How to check keyword ranking in Google.

Sources

More Keyword Rank Tracker answers

All Keyword Rank Tracker guides and answers